Curfews Didn’t Work. Now What?
I remember once being in a car with my parents, and my aunt and uncle. We were visiting my father’s sister, and her husband, and my cousins on Long Island, New York. My Uncle John was a native New Yorker, and my Aunt Bess was originally from Alabama, as a member of my father’s family. She and my Uncle John met in graduate school at Columbia.
One of the benefits of having a sheltered childhood is that it is always fun to be a people watcher, and you feel quite secure, even when it may not be. I sat there among the older generation of my family, and a couple of cousins, and watched in wonder as the adults played their level of social-family politics. My Uncle John was driving, and Aunt Bess was sitting next to him in the front seat. I was sitting behind Uncle John, so I could see the back of his head, and had a clear profile of my aunt as she faced forward, and the complete view of her face when she turned to the left.
My aunt was my father’s younger sister, and was kind of in the role of story teller and host. We were always all glad to see one another, but my aunt and my dad were at the center of that circle of joy, having grown up together. Aunt Bessie was a talker as well, so much of the attention was focused on her, certainly mine. She had a fascinating accent which was part Southern, and part Long Island. I found it endlessly amusing.
On this particular day, riding in their station wagon on the Long Island Expressway, or one of the east-west freeways on the island, I watched my aunt’s face as she operated in the pivot of the conversations, and my uncle’s driving. At one point, my aunt started with what was a subtle signal to my uncle. She said something like, “New Yorkers drive with the absolute faith in their brakes…”, or something like that. What she meant was, drivers there on the L.I. Expressway tend not to coast. They go from acceleration to braking, and back. The driving is very competitive, with little or no moderation. It was all on, or all off. On this particular trip, my aunt was hinting to my uncle to chill out a little bit on his driving. It was hilarious to watch as the comedy and drama played out on her face.
At one moment, she would be talking to the family with this pleasant, smiling affect. She had a face like my father’s and mine, where thoughts and moods were reflected easily. A friend of mine once described mine as a “scoreboard.” Anyway, as my aunt spoke to the family, she had this slight smile. Then she would turn back to face forward and the smile disappeared. She’d have a look of concern and she’d look at my uncle and say, “John.” Uncle John wouldn’t respond. Picture Steve McQueen in “Bullitt”. Not a lot of dialogue. So, I was transfixed by this rapidly changing affect on my aunt’s face.
Occasionally we would approach a bridge. Here is where it got really good. Let’s say there were four lanes on the expressway to pass under the bridge. If my uncle John was one of the drivers, there would be five cars shoulder to shoulder aiming for the four spots, with a couple of the lanes separated by pillars. So, with two families in the car, speeding toward a pillar on the bridge, none of the New Yorkers driving were going to give way. As we approached, my aunt’s head would pivot from front, to left, to front, to left. She’d start saying, “John…John…JOHN!” Then, we’d pass under the bridge without hitting a pillar, and the process would start all over again. “Billy, what position do you play in little league?” “I always use real butter in cobbler, never margarine.” “John…John…JOHN!”
Making it off of that L.I. Expressway alive depended on a great number of things. A small breakdown in any one of the many things that we tend to take for granted could have led to a disastrous outcome. We were fortunate that there was not some unseen pothole, or baby deer causing one driver to swerve. We were lucky that each competitor had a machine that did not fail in the moment, or that one the Steve McQueens didn’t have a heart attack. Each driver seemed to have supreme confidence in their driving skill, and if it absolutely came down to it…the brakes.
Today, I have that feeling again as I watch the social unrest in so many cities around the country. This time, I am not the little leaguer finding amusement in it. Now, I see nothing but the possible dangerous consequences.
Right now, our brakes ain’t what they used to be. Protesters are just not having it anymore. These people seem more determined than I can recall in this country. They are burning government buildings now. Cops are giving way on the streets of the Twin Cities, and in my town of Columbus Ohio. I wondered what they were up to at first, and then I realized, they’re undermanned right now. The closest statistics I could find to this date are from April where police departments are having 17% of their deployments out sick with Covid-19. One sixth is a serious loss, and by late May it could quite possibly be worse in many places.
Now, in times of social unrest, law enforcement agencies employ a sort of all hands on deck deployment strategy. On the LAPD it was called “tactical alert.” During this deployment, we would divide the department in two shifts city wide. Everyone was called back from vacations, and days off were canceled. The entire city would be deployed 12 hours on and 12 hours off until stability returned. It was exhausting, and we had a power advantage back then…for the most part. Today is different. Let’s say a department is down 25% in its workforce. Protecting against a potential riot still requires coverage, so to compensate, you might need to work 25% more hours, so, 15 on and 9 off. Or maybe you cover 25% more territory. Now, I don’t think either of these would be attempted, but this is a way to show how a reduction in resources can strain an already difficult operation. Something has got to give.
Then, add to that the possibility that the police may be adjusting how they engage with the public for concerns about their own health. I am not saying this to engender pity for the officers, but rather to say that this is an additional strain on the machine that we depend on and have taken for granted. The brake pads may be wearing thin.
I saw news footage of a CNN reporter arrested yesterday. We are not accustomed to seeing that in this country. Then early this morning I saw police shooting pepper ball bullets at a local NBC affiliate in Louisville Ky. The officer can plainly be seen aiming and firing at the camera recording the act, from just 15 or 20 feet away. This is not normal for us. I’m not saying that we are better than this. We are just like anyone from anywhere in the world. What I am saying is that we are used to these things blowing over and going back to some semblance of normal.
Some of that “normal” never should have returned before, and it has over, and over. The murder of George Floyd is part of our normal, and people are saying that they are just not having it this time. A compromise has to be reached so that everyone can pass under the bridge that is coming at us. This violence, while tragic, has always been inevitable. I get it. Too many people have been cut out of having any decent shot at a decent life. Not to put this all on Donald Trump, but as one example of the insanity is the fact that this country is simultaneously removing itself from association with the World Health Organization, and suing to eliminate the Affordable Care Act…during a pandemic. That’s not a drop in the bucket of all of the malfeasance, and that, all by itself is insane.
In times like this they used to say, “this too shall pass.” I suppose that still applies. In the meantime, you might want to stay off of the expressway. And if you must, remember that you also have a brake.
Ron Powell
05/30/2020 @ 9:53 am
Black people rescued Joe Biden’s presidential aspirations and presidential campaign.
It looks like the wrongful death of a black man at the hands of the police is rescuing Donald Trump from his incompetence and inability to get out of his own way.
Angry black people in the streets has superseded the coverage of the COVID19 pandemic in the national news cycles for nearly a week with no end in sight.
The failures of Minneapolis prosecutorial authorities and the black response and reactions will dominate the news for the immediate future …
When Trump decides to get involved, his base will jump for joy and applaud with glee as he appears to quell the uprisings and disturbances with a show of mindless force that can result in more violence and escalation of the racial tensions that are displacing concerns regarding his administration’s failures re the national health emergency.
All he has left to run his campaign on is racism…
The murder of a unarmed black man by four white Minneapolis cops, caught on tape by a traumatized black teenaged girl, seems made to order for the racist-in-chief who has been looking for a way to change the subject for the past several months….
Art W. Stone
05/30/2020 @ 10:12 am
The “local” news out of my old home town of Portland has an interview in the moment of a shop owner downtown describe his fears last night as mobs moved through town, pillaging and burning. He was readying his shop to open in pandemic mode. It is flattened, his wares either destroyed or stolen.
It is one of multiple dozens in the same situation.
He will not likely think of George Floyd today.
Bitey
05/30/2020 @ 10:22 am
This is awful. There just aren’t words to adequately describe it.
Bitey
05/30/2020 @ 10:16 am
I think that is a fair accounting. Those numbers have dropped off of the screens on cable news, although the issue goes on. In addition to that, an estimate was given that 33% of all small businesses that closed due to Coronavirus will never re-open. So, dead businesses and dead loved ones will remain as a reminder of Trump’s incompetence even if the numbers never return to the screen.
Some of those Trumpists are losing family and jobs too. We will need to count on them becoming sick of “winning”. It could happen. If it doesn’t, this country does not want to survive.
Art W. Stone
05/30/2020 @ 11:22 am
I stopped watching Portland burn around 2:00 a.m.
Nothing about it gave me any reason to think it will cause a better world to evolve.
Reporters incorrectly stammered that this could not have been predicted.
It seemed to me however, that it was entirely predictable, and more so that predicting a re-occurrence is not like reading tea leaves.
The path wrought by the President’s lack of leadership got us here.
It’s a continuum of the savagery of The Civil War and the failed policies of exclusion and dominance.
This is the immediate future.
A trip to the past.
Koshersalaami
05/30/2020 @ 11:43 am
Yup.
As a friend points out, rioting scares moderates. He also thinks the Republicans will use provocateurs to make the violence worse for electoral reasons. (He’s aware of a history of this and on this he’s a reliable source.)
The strangest aspect of this is that the cop was indicted, unlike in a lot of other cases. That’s at least an improvement – you can’t eliminate crime (on the part of cops like on the part of anyone else) but you should at least punish it. But when are police departments going to figure out that they can’t give their people Carte Blanche any more than they can give the citizenry Carte Blanche? Why would a cop think it was necessary to do that to a cuffed suspect not accused of a violent crime? There are times I think – and I’m probably right – that in certain cities (a lot of them) a cop could take a Black suspect, grab a specially designed portable gas chamber out of his trunk, throw a cuffed suspect in, toss in a couple of pellets of Zyklon-B and a prosecutor and union representatives would say he was justified because he was in fear of his safety.
Seriously, here and in the Eric Garner case you’ve got a suspect cuffed and on the ground, and neither suspect was even accused of a violent crime. How the Hell is a cuffed suspect on the ground a threat to a trained cop? A cuffed suspect on the ground shouldn’t be a threat to a trained twelve year old with a billy club. Policing without limits is for police states. The Israelis exercise more restraint on the West Bank than these guys do and we’re not talking about an occupied population, we’re talking about citizens.
And no key political figure or media figure or media organization is going to come out and say to the American public:
Has it occurred to you why people are rioting?
Do you get how unreasonable and sick and constant this is?
Do you get how intolerable this is and, more to the point, do you get how awful tolerating this is?
I shouldn’t be surprised, because this attitude is not limited to conservatives. I learned that on Open Salon. I’m not an activist in real life. I’ll talk to some people, I’ll write to people, but I haven’t been on the streets in decades, with the exception of helping out with the music program for a gay rights rally in NC when they were defining marriage as between a man and a woman. There were lots of activists (I’ll believe their self-assessments) on that site, but out of the people there I was writing complaining about persecution of more minorities than anyone else I saw there, particularly minorities I didn’t belong to (as well as a lot about the minority I do belong to, but lots of people defended their own minorities). Sure, a lot of them would talk about persecution of Palestinians, which is trendy among liberals, but they wouldn’t talk about anything American Muslims went through. This is not a credit to me, it’s an indictment of everyone else. There should have been nothing above and beyond about that. There is absolutely no way in Hell I should have been in that position on an overwhelmingly liberal site. I shouldn’t have been the only White guy calling the site out on habitual racism – and it shouldn’t have created the most mammoth fight in the site’s history (at least since I arrived in 2010).
Watch the key message get buried. If you don’t want rioting, you shouldn’t allow this to be normal. You can’t justify allowing this to be normal. If you were in this position, you would not tolerate it either.
Of course, that’s another lesson I’ve learned, though far earlier than my blogging: There’s a difference between having a minority mentality and not having one. There are too many Americans, emphatically including liberal Americans, who can’t relate to facing bad official treatment based on who they are, and especially who can’t relate to being unsafe because of who they are. They’ve never experienced it and they don’t actually believe it and, to the extent that they see any of it, they don’t attempt to empathize enough to figure out what life looks like from that position.
Not that a minority mentality helps one empathize with other minorities. Maybe, as sick as it sounds, that’s a Jewish thing. We specifically emphasize that. Not that it was anything like universal among the Jews blogging, but it’s probably why the Freedom Riders were so overwhelmingly Jews. (Not, incidentally, atheists.) We were slaves to Pharoah in Egypt, we are commanded to think of that as applying not just to our ancestors but to us personally, we are reminded of that in prayers on a constant basis, and so Let My People Go was a very natural reaction.
This should be a fucking baseline.
Bitey
05/30/2020 @ 12:12 pm
I don’t have any big answers, but I have a few notions about different questions.
For example.
Everyone assumes that they know what racism is, and in my nearly 57 years, I have rarely seen anyone claim it. I have personally seen people claim to be drug addicts, alcoholics, murderers, rapists, thieves, burglars, and open mullet wearers, but I can only think of one person to say to me that he was a racist. His Name was Al Liveoak, he was a Marine from Alabama, we we got along quite well. We used to go fishing together. He was a hoot!
For some reason, people avoid claiming racism more than anything I can think of. People will even go on at length about why they don’t like you in coded language, but deny being a racist. One blogger was fond of calling me a “nagger”. Now, why does someone go all that way, and then deny racism? What’s more, some others were convinced by the “nagger” ruse. In nearly half a century of thinking about it, I just don’t think we agree about what racism means.
And once free from a solid definition of what it means, lots of people, liberals included, feel free to use it as a lever or a cudgel. Amy Cooper the dog walker in Central Park is a good example. The woman has a graduate degree from University of Chicago. She can’t claim to be a naive waif. She knew the kind of weapon she was using. I think that sort of thing happens all the time, albeit in more subtle ways.
I think racism is like a sort of cultural muscle memory. Certain habits, behaviors, and manners of expression all function as a broad net of racist oppression, and practiced by many who would never want to be a racist oppressor. Our resident Dud Swallow said a few weeks ago that “Spanish Flu” is not racist so he would continue to use the term “Wuhan Flu” rather than Covid-19. In addition to that, liberals were racists for saying “Spanish Flu”, but he was not for saying “Wuhan Flu.” It is an idiotic argument, but it reveals that some do not want to be encumbered with thinking about ethical behaviors, or having an ethical dilemma. They want the clear sailing on placid seas of absolute certainty that they are right. I assume that must be easier somehow. Ethical questions are a struggle. I think racism can be like a selfish shortcut to where you want to go without concern for who’s neck you’re kneeling on. If it worked before, why change?
Jonna Connelly
05/31/2020 @ 3:11 pm
“Has it occurred to you why people are rioting?”
Graffiti on the side of the first supermarket looted Thursday night:
CAN YOU HEAR US NOW?
Ron Powell
06/01/2020 @ 5:03 pm
Jonna:
Re “CAN YOU HEAR US NOW?”
It stops being graffiti when the message alone can stand more powerfully than the artwork that carries it….
jpHart
05/30/2020 @ 2:04 pm
LOGISTICS~~~Sparky!
Of all the words
IF
grin & frown
the best of
whom:
STAND DOWN
I wish I were an
eagleprotectingdoves.
this just in:
Worried ’bout ‘cha Catch 22 are you alright ? aconselba por favor
Aw, thanks, j p
We’re okay. Shit is def going down. We’re just gonna lay low and help where we can.
Thanks for laying eyes on me. Nice to know I got peeps thinking of me.
Sending you ‘that same energy’ as the kids say these days.
See you around, write back anytime,
c-22
jpHart
(@ 500 from Thunder Bay tell us when the children play
I’m in a Warsaw State of Mind
WHAT?! Balsam Lake, WI
U thought Saginaw working the arp-harp on gimme shelter?
How very many.
Right now: Oscars’s helpers & me King of the heap
UBite (whatsIT)
Y
please give HELEN a surf-sucking Francis for me.
Once upon a time filled with tomorrow
fandango I gotta get this rug oo here
skin like iron!
jpHart
05/30/2020 @ 2:26 pm
The Impossible Dream
Andy Williams
To dream the impossible dream
To fight the unbeatable foe
To bear with unbearable sorrow
To run where the brave dare not go
To right the uncharitable wrong
To love pure and chaste from afar
To try when your arms are too weary
To reach the unreachable star
This is my quest, to follow that star
No matter how hopeless, no matter how far
To fight for the right
Without question or pause
To be willing to march
Into hell for a heavenly cause
And I know if I’ll only be true
To this glorious quest
That my heart will lay…
Source: Lyric Find
Ron Powell
05/30/2020 @ 4:22 pm
If racism were to be declared a clinical mental or emotional disorder of some kind, white murderers of unarmed black people would be routinely acquitted by reason of insanity.
Here’s a question worth pondering:
Should the cops who killed George Floyd be charged with committing a ‘hate crime’?
Should the dimensions of a ‘hate crime’ be added to the charges as an ‘aggravating’ element of their guilt?
3rd degree murder/manslaughter is homicide with depraved indifference to human life…
This does little or nothing to address the grievances involved…
Black lives can’t/won’t matter to white folks unless and until black humanity is acknowledged and matters in this society and culture.
If 3rd degree murder is the prosecutorial baseline, be wary of the ‘plea bargain’ that results in the circumvention of ‘criminal justice’ altogether….
Bitey
05/30/2020 @ 5:05 pm
William Prescott at the Battle of Bunker Hill was alleged to have said, “Don’t fire until you see the whites of their eyes.” About 230 years later or so, I got myself into a bit of trouble by wisecracking, “don’t fire until you see the whites…”. Boy, I was a big ol’ racist monster that day.
And although it is not perfectly analogous, I think it is instructive in this sense. At least, it frames my point of view. Your question is, essentially, “should the dimensions of hate crime be added…” to Chauvin’s charges. I see many questions in that question. 1. Does Chauvin deserve the hate crime designation. Yes. 2. Was the act a hate crime. Yes. 3. Can a hate crime designation charge succeed. That I do not know. Sometimes it is easier to prosecute something that can be negotiated down rather than prosecute a higher charge that wont receive a guilty verdict by twelve peers.
So, back to the Bunker Hill. I think I see Chauvin. I have him in my sights. Should I fire? Maybe I get him with the long shot. Or, I can wait until I can make out the inner half of his left eyeball, and take a shot at that. And then my second shot will be to scrape whatever nasal drip remains from the outer half of his nasal cavity. I may graze his ear with the long shot, but he’ll be in a Bosch painting in Hell tonight with the closer shot.
BindleSnitch - He's On His Way
06/01/2020 @ 10:11 pm
[…] Curfews Didn’t Work. Now What? […]