How will you address civil unrest in South Carolina, Take 2
I wrote a recent post about something Sen. Lindsey Graham said in a recent debate. I mischaracterized what he said because it was mischaracterized in my source. I had thought he meant one unacceptable thing; instead he meant another related unacceptable thing.
He was talking about political opportunities for minorities in South Carolina and had used Nikki Haley as an example. And he said this:
“I am asking every African-American out there, look at my record. I care about everybody. If you are a young African-American, an immigrant, you can go anywhere in this state. You just need to be conservative, not liberal. ”
What I thought he meant by “go anywhere” was go anywhere physically. What it looks like he meant was “go anywhere” politically.
So what he was actually saying was:
You cannot be elected to public office (“go anywhere”) in South Carolina if you’re a liberal young African-American or immigrant.
I could go through the syllogism thing again, mainly for Alan’s benefit, but I think I’ll spare you that. I’ll summarize that approach by saying that by the way logic works, which is what “syllogism” is all about, all that “if A, then B” stuff, there is no way that what Graham said doesn’t mean “You cannot be elected to public office in South Carolina if you’re a liberal young African-American or immigrant.” What he said leads unavoidably to that conclusion as sure as 1 + 1 = 2. No room for interpretation, no ambiguity.
The racism here is on the video. He was telling young Blacks and immigrants (but no one else) in South Carolina that if they’re liberal, don’t bother running for public office.
Does he have the authority to say this? Of course not. This is an attempt at racial gatekeeping. He might as well wear a Confederate flag pin. This very obviously says who he is. That he assumes he has the authority to say this is where we run into White Privilege. It remains to be seen whether his White Privilege extends this far. The election will tell us.
But it may get worse. Much worse. It depends on how Graham defines “young.”
Jaime Harrison is forty-four years old. Jaime Harrison is Graham’s Black opponent in this Senate race. Forty-four isn’t old in politics, particularly when you’re sixty-five like Graham is. (I’m slightly older than he is. That is so freaky. I never thought of him as a contemporary.)
If Graham considers Harrison young, then Graham just said that his opponent can’t get elected because he’s Black. On television. With Harrison present.
Under normal circumstances I’d say “Naah. Graham’s too much of a pro to go that far.” But what he did say was so far beyond the pale that all bets are off.
Ron Powell
10/13/2020 @ 5:46 pm
My comment on the matter, as posted in your ‘first take’, stands as is:
“Graham’s message is an exercise in southern style white privilege.
His opponent is a young black man who is giving Graham a run for his money. Painting him as ‘liberal’ makes him a target.
Graham has gone ‘retro’ and is taking a page out of the Jim Crow political playbook….
As such, the ‘message’ is both a warning and an admonition, just short of an overt threat of violence against the ‘liberal’ candidate and his supporters….”
What surprises me is that you needed ‘second take’…
“…Graham just said that his opponent can’t get elected because he’s Black. On television. With Harrison present….”
That kind of talk can get Harrison killed, and Graham knows it…
Bitey
10/13/2020 @ 9:44 pm
BINGO!
Koshersalaami
10/13/2020 @ 8:05 pm
I needed second take because my first take was inaccurate and the first thing I needed to do was own that I gave out bad information.
Jonna Connelly
10/16/2020 @ 1:55 pm
I sometimes wonder if Lindsay doesn’t have some dementia going on. Even with southern white privilege, he’s experienced enough to know better than to say this in public.
Koshersalaami
10/16/2020 @ 2:17 pm
Maybe his unusual support for Trump is based on blackmail of some sort and he’s stressed out of his mind. Could be anything.
koshersalaami
11/17/2020 @ 10:46 am
And, in other news about Sen. Graham’s fall from anything resembling ethical behavior, in today’s NY Times it is reported that Georgia Sec. of State Brad Raffensperger, a Republican, has stated that Graham and others pressured him to throw out legally cast ballots for Democrats.